Yet when it comes to the surfaces used to clean and apply them, we give little thought.
Whether it’s the kitchen towels used to dry your produce, or the bath towel used to dry your skin, not much thinking goes into them.
Even if your lettuce is thoroughly rinsed and you wear organic sunscreen, how do those benefits compare to the potential dangers of your dirty towels and washcloths?
Some say the solution is silver-infused bath towels and dish rags. However, there might be safety issues with those, too.
Before we review the BacLock towels by Norwex, it’s important to note that these inhibit bacteria growth, NOT viruses. Norwex is NOT suitable for sanitizing surfaces from viruses.
If you’re looking for a cleaning cloth that is at least 99% effective against killing viruses such as influenza or the novel COVID-19 coronavirus, the EPA published “List N: EPA’s Registered Antimicrobial Products for Use Against Novel Coronavirus SARS-CoV-2, the Cause of COVID-19.” (5) It includes products such as Clorox disinfecting wipes.
Organic and natural cleaners are not considered effective at killing viruses on surfaces.
What is Norwex BacLock?
Founded in 1994, Norwex is a Norwegian multi-level marketing company focused on selling household cleaning products which reduce or eliminate the need for added chemicals.
Norwex’s flagship product is the EnviroCloth. It’s a microfiber cleaning cloth which contains BacLock.
BacLock is the trademarked name for a silver-based antibacterial agent built into Norwex’s microfiber products. Those include bath towels, reusable napkins, dish mats, mop pads, veggie and fruit scrubs, pet towels, and other cleaning/hygiene articles.
The bestselling brand of antimicrobial towels is BacLock, however there are others which use silver-infused threading.
Originally started on Kickstarter, Silvon bed sheets, pillowcases, and towels are made with silver-coated threads, interwoven with organic cotton. Reviews are generally positive.
Canadian-based SilverClear is an antibacterial and bactericidal coating which is used on woven and non-woven textiles.
Do antibacterial towels work?
Some allege that Norwex doesn’t work, or that the antimicrobial claims are not true. They say this because either the towels smells develop a mildew smell, or because the surfaces they clean can still harbor mold and bacteria.
People misconstrue the BacLock claimed benefit, which is that it’s “an antibacterial agent for self-cleansing purposes only.” That means it works for inhibiting new bacteria and mildew growth within the towel itself. It does not not kill bacteria or viruses on other surfaces you wipe clean, such as countertops and cutting boards.How Norwex BacLock and similar towels work is by releasing silver ions, which interfere with the growth and spread of bacteria. This is accomplished by interfering with an enzyme that bacteria need for their oxygen metabolism; the transmembrane transport. The silver also damages their DNA, which interferes with their reproductive process.
Unlike chemical sprays which typically kill bacteria within seconds minutes, the time it takes for a silver-infused cloth takes longer; from one hour to a day. Even though it doesn’t kill the bacteria on contact when wiping a counter, many or most of the microbes will adhere to the microfiber cloth. Then as time passes, those on the cloth will die off. That’s how BacLock works.
The antimicrobial properties of this molecule are well documented, both scientifically and historically.
Before people even knew microorganisms existed, water jugs made of silver were prized because people seemed to be less prone to sickness when drinking from them. It was used in wound dressings, right up ’til the invention of antibiotics in the 1940’s. (1)
There are numerous lab experiments and studies which demonstrate how silver inhibits bacterial growth, when in proper concentration and in a solution or on a material that allows for direct contact.
The above photo shows cultures of Staphylococcus aureus, Enterococcus faecalis and Escherichia coli after being exposed to fabrics infused with silver nanoparticles for one hour. On the rayon fabric, there is a 97% or better reduction. On the cotton gauze, there is a 100% reduction. (2)
Yes, BacLock really works, though not in the way many believe. It inhibits bacterial growth within the cloth. It’s not suitable for sanitizing your kitchen or bathroom.
Is BacLock safe?
Whether it’s Norwex BacLock or other cleaning cloths with silver in them, they are not safe for food prep. They don’t kill germs instantly on contact, nor do they fully sanitize the surface they wipe.
Colloidal silver and nanoparticles have little to no efficacy on viruses like influenza or the rhinovirus, which causes the common cold, because viruses don’t have cell walls. Therefore, that mechanism of action doesn’t work. Although not specifically tested, one can assume the same for COVID-19 coronavirus; such products are NOT effective at killing viruses of any type.
Just as silver ions are bad for bacteria, they also may be harmful to your skin cells.
They can have a pro-oxidant effect; meaning they induce oxidative stress.
In an experiment where human skin fibroblast cells were cultured in petri dishes, the addition of silver ions increased the production of reactive oxygen species (oxidants) in dose-dependent manner.
The amount of oxidative damage was comparable to hydrogen peroxide (H2O2). That chemical is often used in experiments as a positive control, because it’s a potent inducer of oxidative stress in humans and animals. (3)
Colloidal silver may interfere with viral growth by oxidizing them, but not enough to be considered an effective anti-viral cleaner.
Silver towels and bath mats, including Norwex BacLock body cloths, work by releasing silver ions. The process is slow, as they last for dozens of washes. Norwex has a 2-year warranty on their Enviro Cloth.
The released silver ions come in contact with your skin and those can cause oxidative stress. Therefore, it may be bad for your hands to hold them during cleaning. For the same reason, fast drying antibacterial bath towels may be bad for your body.
That being said, any potential harm or danger may be less than the oxidative stress caused by chemicals found in common cleaning products and harsh soaps.
Still, this is a safety concern about cleaning cloths and towels with silver in them that needs more research, in order to quantify the risk and compare it.
Arizona State University conducted a study where they measured the release of nanosilver from silver-infused consumer products such as shirts, medical masks, toys (teddy bears), bath towels, toothpaste, shampoo, and laundry detergent.
In the study, they raised several alarming points and emphasized how the problem is not regulated by the FDA or similar government bodies:
“Because government does not specifically regulate the use of nanosilver in products, the onus of protecting human and environmental health from potential adverse effects currently falls on individuals.”
In short, silver-containing cleaning clothes are a viewed as a “natural” alternative to traditional cleaning chemicals. Even though the adverse reactions may not be as profound as bleach and other caustic chemicals, there are possible side effects to consider in terms of the microscopic effect they may be having on the skin, as well as the environment. (4)
These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.